If the complicated role of a magician could be distilled to just one core job, it would definitely be to fool their audience. The stated premise of Josh Staley’s Fool Me Once is thus in a way the first time of the evening that he fulfills his core duties—he does, in the end, fool his audience more than once. It’s a simple premise and Staley uses it effectively.

Staley uses both sleight of hand magic and mentalism to fool the audience. An early highlight is his coin routine. In fact, at the reviewed show, as he completed this routine a member of the audience audibly whispered to her friends, “I love the coins”, a sentiment that, at that point, was surely shared by everyone else watching, and which Staley confirmed that he shared as well. Staley also read several minds, both from written prompts and from words that existed solely in the minds of his audience members.

Audience participation in Fool Me Once is used thoughtfully and effectively. Several participants are able to get involved from their seats, including for an exciting finale to the above-mentioned beloved coin routine that sees a magical element happen in the hands of an audience member. When audience participants get more involved, whether in coming onstage to have a turn at presenting a reveal or even just completing an impressive shuffle, Staley celebrates their achievements and makes sure they get applause for their contribution to his show.

It’s not always a good sign when the magician has to deal with significant numbers of audience member mistakes and interruptions, but at the reviewed show Staley dealt with several such matters with exemplary professionalism. An early example saw a participant helping Staley with a card trick misunderstand his instructions to hide her chosen card in the deck, instead hiding it under his box of props. On discovering this miscommunication Staley recovered the effect with a joke and a well performed bit of sleight of hand. Staley also had to contend with a gaggle of chatty youngsters, and managed to shut down their side conversations with quick good humor.

The reviewed show of Fool Me Once was nearly if not entirely sold out, on a Saturday evening in Adelaide at a prime time slot with plenty of competition. It’s no surprise, it’s a well staged show and Staley is a charming performer. If any tickets remain for the rest of his Fringe run future audiences will surely have to hurry to nab them.